Especially for Lawyers: Why So Many Wheelchair Tipovers, Part 2

In almost every one of the 150+ lawsuits I serve on as an expert in wheelchair securement, I found a single, common element: The vehicle was running behind schedule. Further, most of the schedules were too tight: The only way a driver could not fall further behind schedules was to commit constant safety compromises to shave minutes and seconds off the vehicle’s often on-the-street “running time.”

While there are many reasons for this, the main one, by far, is the fact that human beings simply cannot schedule shared rides. At least Americans can’t This fact is all the more extraordinary when one compares it to the ease of scheduling fixed route service. One embarrassing but true story places this comparison in perspective.

Origins of School Bus Service

Pupil transportation service actually began before the emergence of buses. In rural areas, large family-owned farms typically lay miles apart. Particularly during the planting season (the Spring) and harvesting season (the Fall), a farmer could not take his son or daughter to a school miles away – in a buckboard (those used for this transportation were derisively referred to as “kid hacks”) where the horse may have trotted eight to 12 miles per hour. And each farmer doing this could not possibly perform this task for his child or children every day. So, as a result, a group of farmers whose farms resided somewhat close together consolidated these operations: They devoted (or bought) a farm wagon or buckboard, with bench seats, to a group of students

Now the ramifications for public transportation begin to become interesting. Since none of these farmers could do this every day, few could do it even once a week. But they didn’t need do. Designing a fixed route – like present-day schoolbus service – a route was developed starting with the child living the furthest from the “one-room schoolhouse” (usually accommodating children of all ages and sorted into grades which soon morphed into kindergarten and then the next grade from grade one to whatever. All children did not attend 12 years of elementary school, and few rural children attended college.

But an amazing capability solved this problem. The “farm wagon” and its horse was stored at the farm the furthest from the school. So on the first day of school, that farm’s owner (or a farm hand) drove the buckboard, picking up the rest of the children along the route. When the trip was long, that horse, drive and wagon just lay around during the school day – rather than “deadhead” all the way back to the initial farm, only to head back to school at the end of the day to pick the student up. Plus, this “deadhead” back to the starting farm, and mix up the horse. Mixing up the horse was a problem, since starting on the second day of school, the horse ran the route, picking up the students, WITHOUT A DRIVER. In other words, the horse memorized the route! Some horses may have received a bit of guidance or prodding by one of the passengers. But essentially, after the first day of school, the schoolbus resembled what today are known as “autonomous vehicles,” and traveled, again, for the rest of the school year, without a driver.

This principle is especially important to absorb today when almost no schoolbus driver needs to ever learn the route. Unless he or she knows the service area, the driver of a motorized schoolbus need not know anything: He or she simply gets the list of students to pick up and drop off, their destinations, and the sequence of pickups (on the way to school in the mornings) or drop-offs (on the way home from school in the afternoon), and punches in each destination in his or her phone. More typically, a modern schoolbus driver was given a sequential list of students – known for at least half a century as a “log” or “manifest,” and follows it. In a few days the driver learns the route. But the point is, beyond investing in this vehicle (used for little else) and its fuel (diesel fuel in place of a small barrel of oats), this vehicle also requires a driver, who must be paid. This motorized vehicle costs more than any horse, its operating expenses (fuel and maintenance) and the need for a driver cost considerably more than a horse-and-buggy 130 years ago. In trade-off, motorized schoolbuses travel much faster (where the roadways permit them to), and the students’ trip to and from school is much shorter. And either the students do not have to arise as early and return home too late to do much useful farm work, or the school day is longer, and they learn more. And, of course, many other things have changes as densities increased, schools were separated into three types (elementary, middle school –typically junior high school until the 1970s — and high school). And far more students complete all 12 years of school (plus kindergarten, and today, pre-school for many), and an increasing number attend college. In the 1950s or so, only five percent of our students attended college. By 2022, more than 61 percent of high school students attended some former of higher education (college or junior college).

Back to transportation, the point is that a fixed route was so simple that with one day’s practice, the horse ran the route without a driver. (Now, using my phone, I still can’t find certain destinations – after attending them at least 10 times – without my phone.), If I had to follow a different route every day, I could never do it without my phone – unless I practically grew up in that service area, and travel extensively within it for decades. Before “navigators” (i.e., map “apps” on a cellphone, a valuable and highly-praised capability of a driver was his or her knowledge of the service area. During my decade directing the operations of my own 70-vehicle paratransit system from 1982 to 1992, someone with little or no knowledge of the service area was our last choice in the hiring practice (beyond those drivers with criminal records, poor eyesight, bad employment histories or other obvious reasons to not hire that driver candidate).

What does this evolution tell us? First, and most obvious, as a society, we are greatly underutilizing the intelligence of our animals. But for transportation, the fact that with a log and little or no practice, the schoolbus cannot run the route without a driver. This lesson is critical to an understanding of demand-responsive transportation, where the passengers, origins, destinations and routes differed every day – and why in the early 1990s, most schedulers were replaced with “scheduling software” – effectively robots. Most early programs could schedule more efficiently than an “average” scheduler, but not as well as a good scheduler (as I was).

As an aside, while this series covers wheelchair tipovers, this article’s digression lays the groundwork for it – groundwork that has far less to do with one’s ability to secure a wheelchair than many other factors.

So in one tragic sense, this series of articles about demand responsive transportation is the story of an industry that went backwards – a direction most transportation modes have been headed for decades now, and depending on one’s political persuasion, a legitimate part of what has been termed “the dead state” – which Elon Musk might have discovered were he not so preoccupied with saving money only by starving hundreds of thousands of people (mostly children) in Africa.

In some fundamental ways, some forms of transportation were dramatically more efficient 130 years ago than they are today. But when shared ride, demand-responsive service emerged in the 1970s, live Earthlings were no match for it, and wheelchair tipovers became rampant.

#schoolbusservice #autonomousvehicles #publictransitexpert #transalt